"...a well-written, scholarly study that offers novel, thought-provoking notions for further research. It is a welcome addition to the growing field of Italian film scholarship and will be very useful in Italian American film courses." --
Annali d'Italianistica "...
The Transatlantic Gaze offers a thought-provoking analysis of what happens when cinematic worlds collide." --
Journal of Transatlantic Studies "One of the principal merits of this book is its structural and expository clarity ... This clearly written text is of interest to those in the field and ... to those who are unfamiliar with the subject matter. An easy and pleasant read, while at the same time rich and stimulating, McDonald Carolan's book constitutes a significant contribution to the analysis of the links between national cinemas." --
Italica "...a meticulous work of love that juxtaposes some of the best Italian and American films produced since the end of World War II up until the second decade of the new millennium in order to unveil the influence of Italian cinema on American film ... The detailed analyses of this scrupulous work are of interest not only to scholars of cinema and Italian studies, but also to those engaged in comparative, cultural, American and Italian-American studies." --
Journal of Modern Italian Studies "...an excellent reference for scholars ... Innovative, well-written and well-argued,
The Transatlantic Gaze not only represents an important contribution to the field of film studies, but also to the area of Italian cultural studies, inserting itself into a series of works that study the influence of Italian culture but are written in English and thus directed towards an anglophone audience." --
Journal of Italian Cinema and Media Studies "...insightful ... In detailed readings and comparisons, and thanks in part to the well-chosen quotations that she meticulously analyzes, Carolan is masterful in acknowledging the tremendous impact that the Italian filmmakers have had on their American counterparts." --
CHOICE "...Carolan has written an astutely focused text on a universally acknowledged subject, but one that is rarely covered these days, even in academia ... this book is an excellent reference for scholars and could provide movie buffs or Italophiles with a wealth of film trivia." --
San Francisco Book Review