Envisioning a different mode of economic relations requires a rethinking of the classical frames of references we commonly take for granted. The implicit assumptions that we carry into critical debates are the stumbling blocks for finding useful solutions to age-old economic problems. And these impediments constrict our political imagination.
This book asks what are these frames of references? How many of them are worthy of retaining, while others might be discarded? And what new framings should be adopted in order to bring about a less crisis-prone and morally acceptable mode of human interaction?
Each chapter interrogates a different frame of reference, including culturally-embedded concepts of human nature, scarcity and abundance, markets, and the human condition. Examining their historical anchoring and the ways in which they have become confining for the realities of the postmodern world in which we currently live, it is shown that they have become so familiar that they are assumed rather than critically examined in most discussions of political economy.
Die Inhaltsangabe kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.
Raphael Sassower is Professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Colorado at Colorado Springs. He is author of The Price of Public Intellectuals (2014), Digital Exposure: Postmodern Postcapitalism (2013), Solo: Postmodern Explorations (2011) and Postcapitalism: Moving Beyond Ideology in Economic Crises (2009).
Foreword, vii,
Preface, xiii,
Acknowledgments, xix,
Part I: Assumptions Underlying Theories,
1 Abundance/Scarcity: From the Garden of Eden to Utopia, 3,
2 The State of Nature and the Social Contract, 35,
3 Human Nature and the Human Condition, 49,
4 Individual versus Communal Property Rights, 67,
5 Markets, 87,
6 Economic Growth, 113,
Part II: Framing Theories,
7 Dangerous Assumptions, 129,
8 Useful Assumptions, 139,
9 Alternative Models and the Question of Scale, 149,
Part III: Current Models,
10 Contemporary Capitalisms and Their Faults, 163,
11 The Perils of Globalization, 183,
12 Remixing and the Knockoff Economy, 201,
13 Marketing the Sharing Economy, 217,
Part IV: Reframing Political Economy,
14 Informative Case Studies, 241,
15 Moral Framing of Political Economy, 269,
Epilogue, 301,
Bibliography, 311,
Index, 323,
Abundance/Scarcity
From the Garden of Eden to Utopia
Most historical or historically informed texts that deal with theories of political economy, from John Locke and Adam Smith to more contemporary ones by Milton Friedman and behavioral economists, assume that scarcity is our natural condition. If indeed natural resources are scarce, then certain other factors are bound to frame the discussion of production, distribution, and consumption. For example, questions of efficient resource allocation become paramount, whether the good under examination is energy or food. But if scarcity is only an assumption rather than a reality, and if instead abundance is the natural condition under which to make political and economic decisions, then many theories and the policy decisions based on them should be changed. My interest here is to outline the genealogy of this frame of reference and suggest that particular ideological interests have foregrounded scarcity rather than abundance. Though offered as brief vignettes, what follows is supposed to offer a picture of natural abundance that somehow has disappeared for a long time, until revisited more recently under the guise of technological innovations, industrial and digital.
I: DEFINITIONS
Among the definitions of scarcity found in the Oxford English Dictionary, one can note those associated with positive attributes concerned with saving and preservation, such as frugality and parsimony. But amid these definitions one can also find some associated with negative attributes, such as niggardliness, stinginess, and meanness. Regardless of one's inclination to consider the term either positively or negatively, one can appreciate the ubiquity of the term scarcity and the ambiguous meaning it has in certain social, political, and economic practices. Should society abhor scarcity and try to overcome it whenever and however possible? Or, should society resign itself to the "facts of life or nature" and accept scarcity as unavoidable? Should scarcity be welcomed and manipulated to some advantage? Or, should it be overcome to "create" abundance?
More useful definitions in the Oxford English Dictionary (OED ) emphasize the "insufficiency of supply; smallness of available quantity, number, or amount, in proportion to the need or demand." In support of this particular definition, John S. Mill's Political Economy is quoted: "things which cannot be increased ad libitum in quantity, and which therefore, if the demand goes beyond a certain amount, command a scarcity value" (III, iv, section 6, (1876 edition), 283). A comment about value is added: "an enhanced value due to scarcity." This particular definition may be troubling to most economists, since the adjective enhanced makes no sense. Either there is value due to scarcity — scarcity is defined as lending value to things — or there is no value; what does it mean to have "enhanced value"? In addition, the OED uses the following terms to identify scarcity: "comparative fewness ... rare," "scantiness," "inadequate provision of the necessities of life — hardship." Here the emphasis is on the problem inherent in certain "things": they cannot be "increased" at will. Things, such as water and air, were considered unproblematic for a long time, so that the notion of scarcity could not be applied to them. Singling out water and air has become a historical anachronism: water and air alike are scarce in the sense described above. So, does that mean that water and air "command a scarcity value" in the sense of "an enhanced value"? Since the answer is affirmative, one must wonder if there is any "thing" left today that will fall outside of Mill's classification. If the answer is negative, according to most environmentalists, then this classification is of no help; it is too broad: everything is scarce by definition.
Can Mill's definition be rescued if scarcity is distinguished from shortage, for example, in the sense that there can be shortage of everything but only certain things are considered scarce? According to Janos Kornai (1980, Introduction), the notions of scarcity and abundance are more fundamental than the notion of shortage. He is not interested in describing or criticizing a system of economic activities, capitalist or socialist, which fails to accomplish a set of goals, such as bringing to an equilibrium the production and consumption of the system, the supply and demand portions of the economy. The notion of shortage is exclusively concerned with the failure of the system, and is therefore an internal problem, not one through which a critique of the whole theoretical framework of political economy can be handled. One may argue that an internal critique, what critical theorists call an immanent critique, can provide insights fundamental to the very conception of the system/model/theory that is criticized. Just as in the case of shortages (chronic or temporary) in a socialist society, one would be providing a parallel but not identical examination of the problem of unemployment and underutilization of resources in a capitalist society.
So, the notion of scarcity is different from that of shortage at least in the sense that the former is considered more fundamental than the latter. More fundamental in what sense? According to Kornai, in the sense of being able to correct shortages, either of capitalist or socialist economies, while being unable to overcome scarcity. Scarcity, then, is not an artificial human construct or invention, but is understood as a natural given. However, phrasing the question of scarcity in empirical terms has itself been open to critical evaluations over the years. That is, it remains unclear what the empirical status of scarcity was, is, and will be.
II: THE GARDEN OF EDEN
The Bible is similarly confusing on these questions. While the narrative of creation in Genesis bespeaks of abundance, and the picture in the Garden of Eden is considered an ideal materialized by divine will for the sake of Adam and Eve, there is also the story of the expulsion from that very Garden. Once Adam and Eve leave the state of abundance, where they roam freely and need not work for their subsistence, Adam's curse is that he should earn his bread by the sweat of his brow. Does this curse turn the human condition around, and change...
„Über diesen Titel“ kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.
Anbieter: Maxwell's House of Books, La Mesa, CA, USA
Soft cover. Zustand: Very Good. A beautiful, tight, unmarked softcover in very good condition; light edge wear. We are a brick-and-mortar store and sell our own inventory. We will refuse any orders from book brokers and drop shippers. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 071561
Anzahl: 1 verfügbar
Anbieter: GreatBookPrices, Columbia, MD, USA
Zustand: As New. Unread book in perfect condition. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 25524734
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: GreatBookPrices, Columbia, MD, USA
Zustand: New. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 25524734-n
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: Grand Eagle Retail, Bensenville, IL, USA
Paperback. Zustand: new. Paperback. Envisioning a different mode of economic relations requires a rethinking of the classical frames of references we commonly take for granted. The implicit assumptions that we carry into critical debates are the stumbling blocks for finding useful solutions to age-old economic problems. And these impediments constrict our political imagination. This book asks what are these frames of references? How many of them are worthy of retaining, while others might be discarded? And what new framings should be adopted in order to bring about a less crisis-prone and morally acceptable mode of human interaction? Each chapter interrogates a different frame of reference, including culturally-embedded concepts of human nature, scarcity and abundance, markets, and the human condition. Examining their historical anchoring and the ways in which they have become confining for the realities of the postmodern world in which we currently live, it is shown that they have become so familiar that they are assumed rather than critically examined in most discussions of political economy. This book asks what are the common assumptions - or frames of references - that underlie our understanding of political economy today. How many of them are worthy of retaining? Could others be discarded? This item is printed on demand. Shipping may be from multiple locations in the US or from the UK, depending on stock availability. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 9781783489305
Anbieter: Ria Christie Collections, Uxbridge, Vereinigtes Königreich
Zustand: New. In English. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers ria9781783489305_new
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: GreatBookPricesUK, Woodford Green, Vereinigtes Königreich
Zustand: New. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 25524734-n
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: GreatBookPricesUK, Woodford Green, Vereinigtes Königreich
Zustand: As New. Unread book in perfect condition. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 25524734
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: THE SAINT BOOKSTORE, Southport, Vereinigtes Königreich
Paperback / softback. Zustand: New. This item is printed on demand. New copy - Usually dispatched within 5-9 working days. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers C9781783489305
Anzahl: Mehr als 20 verfügbar
Anbieter: Books Puddle, Woodside, NY, USA
Zustand: New. pp. 348. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 26385708569
Anzahl: 1 verfügbar
Anbieter: Majestic Books, Hounslow, Vereinigtes Königreich
Zustand: New. pp. 348. Bestandsnummer des Verkäufers 378195398
Anzahl: 1 verfügbar