Accuracy and Traceability in Speciation Analysis

PHILIPPE QUEVAUVILLER

1 Introduction

Traceability issues are of increasing concern in all fields where chemical measurements form the basis for decisions. The concepts of accuracy and traceability as applied to environmental analysis are, however, still prone to misunderstanding. Some years ago, Horwitz stated that 'considerable evidence exists in the literature that few analytical chemists pay attention to the question of the reliability of the analytical results they produce. These chemists believe that a natural law exists in measurement science, that if the directions for conducting a measurement are followed, the true value necessarily results'. This corresponds to the long-term debate about precision or reproducibility over accuracy, which is now relayed by ongoing discussions on accuracy and traceability: while accuracy refers to the closeness of analytical values to 'true values' (trueness) and among various repetitions (precision), the term traceability implies a link between the data obtained and established references, through an unbroken chain of comparisons, all with stated uncertainties. Recent controversial discussions have illustrated the misunderstanding, which may occur among the analytical community with respect to accuracy and traceability issues in the area of speciation analysis, with possible consequences on environmental data interpretation.

Speciation analysis is no longer a new feature. IUPAC defines this term as 'the analytical activity of identifying and measuring the quantity of one or more individual chemical species in a sample'. The speciation of an element is defined as 'the distribution of defined chemical species of an element in a system'. Chemical species of some elements (e.g. organotins, organomercury compounds) are now included in the list of substances to be determined in the frame of international environmental programmes, requiring an increasing knowledge and care with respect to the quality control (including traceability issues) of all monitoring steps (from sampling to reporting data).

Analytical techniques used for the determination of chemical species are generally based on a succession of steps (e.g. extraction, derivatisation, separation, detection) all of which are prone to various sources of systematic errors. Within the last decade, international collaborative efforts (through inter-laboratory studies and certification of reference materials) have enabled the systematic study of hyphenated techniques used for the determination of chemical species of, e.g., arsenic, chromium, mercury, lead, tin and selenium in environmental matrices (water, fish or mussel tissues, sediments). The determination of operationally-defined element fractions (extractable forms of trace elements) in sediment and soil matrices has also been collaboratively studied, mainly to harmonise and standardise extraction schemes, in order to improve the comparability of data (stressing that, strictly speaking, this type of determination should not be covered by the term 'speciation'). In this context, all of these collaborative efforts have been understood as being directed towards the drive for accuracy (trueness and precision as defined below). It has been recognised recently that these achievements have actually led primarily to the establishment of reference points (e.g. certified values in reference materials), which do not necessarily correspond to 'true values', but offer a mean with which laboratories may compare their data internationally and, hence, achieve traceability. This ambiguity still generates confusion and misunderstanding among the scientific community. This chapter discusses this issue, focusing on analytical measurements only. Extending discussions on general traceability issues would imply an examination of steps prior to laboratory work (sampling, storage, etc.) which is beyond the scope of this contribution.

2 Accuracy

The accuracy concept covers the terms trueness and precision. Trueness is defined as 'the closeness of agreement...